clique
NumbersMarketsMarket sizeHow it worksGuaranteePricingBlogBook a call
← All markets
Market 05, Commercial finance and B2B accounting 6 documented months

Commercial finance and B2B accounting

6
Documented months
each one a dated Instantly panel
16 to 75
Positive replies a month
lowest and highest of the 6
32
Median positive replies
across these months
50 qualified leads a quarter on the quarterly plan, or we keep working free. Read the guarantee

Every reply count on this page is read straight off that panel.

We forward a positive reply to the client and stop there. What closed after that is confidential, the same reason none of these companies are named. So there are no meeting counts and no close rates here. What each Result adds is what the replies themselves looked like.

Lists start with a data provider and are then enriched for a buying signal, which gives every email something specific to say.

01

September 2019

low
Campaign results for September 2019, 25 positive replies from 21,294 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, September 2019. 2,283 replies in total, 25 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

A three broker asset finance firm in Brisbane.

Problem

All their work came through two dealership relationships and word of mouth from past clients, so they heard about a purchase only after the dealer had already arranged finance in the showroom.

Solution

We enriched the list against fleet and plant registration ages, which told us whose gear was near replacement. Those owners got an email about the equipment they were about to replace. The first list was by industry code and was far too broad, so it got rebuilt on fleet age. A rate comparison offer worked better than an equipment finance introduction.

Result

25 positive replies. Every reply was passed over to their team. Most were owners already partway through a purchase.

02

November 2020

low
Campaign results for November 2020, 16 positive replies from 14,008 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, November 2020. 1,307 replies in total, 16 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

A five person commercial finance brokerage in Melbourne.

Problem

Every conversation that year was about deferring existing loans, not writing new ones.

Solution

The list narrowed to businesses that had grown through the year, food manufacturing and last mile delivery, where equipment was genuinely being bought. A first pass at the full client base pulled in deferral questions they could not bill for. The two lists were deduplicated against each other, since the same names kept turning up in both.

Result

16 positive replies. We forward the reply and stop there. A good share were still deferral questions, which is what November looked like.

03

February 2022

average
Campaign results for February 2022, 25 positive replies from 18,425 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, February 2022. 1,767 replies in total, 25 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

An invoice finance brokerage in Leeds, six people.

Problem

Their previous provider had sent 40,000 emails over eight months for a five figure fee and produced a spreadsheet of bounced addresses. Factoring also has a reputation problem, and naming the product ended most conversations before they started.

Solution

The list was enriched from the payment terms published on their own invoices and terms pages, so we knew who was waiting 60 days before writing a word. The email was about that wait, and never named the product until the call. The list came from firms with long payment terms visible on their own invoices and terms pages. An early version mentioning cash flow got lumped in with lender spam, so that phrase came out.

Result

25 positive replies. Replies were forwarded to their team. Nobody replying knew they were talking to a factoring broker, which was deliberate.

04

October 2023

average
Campaign results for October 2023, 39 positive replies from 20,228 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, October 2023. 2,061 replies in total, 39 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

An equipment finance firm in Phoenix, 11 people.

Problem

Rate rises made their whole pitch about cheap money useless in about six weeks.

Solution

The angle switched from cheap money to freeing up cash, aimed at owners who had recently bought equipment outright. A sale and leaseback offer replaced the finance introduction. The first list included leasing companies, which was an obvious error and cost the first fortnight.

Result

39 positive replies. Each one was passed across to them. A fair number were fishing for a rate and nothing else.

05

September 2024

strong
Campaign results for September 2024, 63 positive replies from 23,146 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, September 2024. 1,752 replies in total, 63 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

An eight person accounting firm in Adelaide moving into advisory work.

Problem

They had put a junior on outbound for six months with no training and no process, and the only thing it produced was a burnt list and a view that cold email does not work.

Solution

We enriched a business list for headcount growth over the previous 18 months, which is when the bookkeeper starts falling behind. Those owners got an email about the numbers they were not getting, with a fixed price diagnostic as the entry. The first version pitched advisory services generally and got nothing. Naming one specific report they were missing changed the response rate.

Result

63 positive replies. We hand the reply across and step out. Most were owners who already knew what was missing and had never been asked about it.

06

February 2025

great
Campaign results for February 2025, 75 positive replies from 16,581 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, February 2025. 1,358 replies in total, 75 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

A commercial finance brokerage in Glasgow, nine people, construction focused.

Problem

Their deals came from one accountant referral partner, which meant three good months then two empty ones. That partner had just been acquired by a national firm with its own broker.

Solution

We enriched the list against which main contractors each firm worked under, since that predicts how long they wait to get paid. Owners of construction and fit out firms got an email about retentions, opening with a facility review. A version aimed at finance directors underperformed, so the list moved to owners. Volume built each week rather than starting at full pace, since the domains were new, which is why the back half of February carried most of it.

Result

75 positive replies. From the reply onward it was their sales team, not us. Retentions was the word that got responses, every time, and nine people could not work 75 of them quickly.

Other markets we have run this in

Same method, different buyers. Every month on these pages is a dated screenshot.

AI automation and implementation4 documented months, median 37 positive repliesSee the campaignsB2B SaaS selling to SMB and mid-market6 documented months, median 30 positive repliesSee the campaignsCommercial cleaning, facilities and maintenance6 documented months, median 32 positive repliesSee the campaignsFreight forwarding, 3PL and logistics7 documented months, median 31 positive repliesSee the campaignsManaged IT and cybersecurity6 documented months, median 23 positive repliesSee the campaignsManufacturing and industrial suppliers7 documented months, median 28 positive repliesSee the campaignsRecruitment and staffing agencies6 documented months, median 31 positive repliesSee the campaignsSoftware development and staff augmentation6 documented months, median 33 positive repliesSee the campaignsSpecialist marketing services6 documented months, median 26 positive repliesSee the campaignsVideo production6 documented months, median 29 positive repliesSee the campaignsWholesale, private label and B2B suppliers6 documented months, median 26 positive repliesSee the campaignsAll 12 marketsEvery market on one pageSee them all

Worth reading before a call

PerformanceCold Email Open Rates, Reply Rates, and What the Numbers Actually MeanRead itLead generationHow to Generate Leads for Your Business (Without a Guessing Game)Read itStrategyIf Cold Email Works So Well, Why Isn't Everyone Doing It?Read it

Taking new campaigns

Want to see the numbers?

Send us who you sell to and roughly how many companies fit that description. One call is usually enough to tell whether the guarantee will hold for your market, and if it will not we would rather say so before you pay.