clique
NumbersMarketsMarket sizeHow it worksGuaranteePricingBlogBook a call
← All markets
Market 01, Recruitment and staffing agencies 6 documented months

Recruitment & staffing

6
Documented months
each one a dated Instantly panel
20 to 67
Positive replies a month
lowest and highest of the 6
31
Median positive replies
across these months
50 qualified leads a quarter on the quarterly plan, or we keep working free. Read the guarantee

Every reply count on this page is read straight off that panel.

We forward a positive reply to the client and stop there. What closed after that is confidential, the same reason none of these companies are named. So there are no meeting counts and no close rates here. What each Result adds is what the replies themselves looked like.

Lists start with a data provider and are then enriched for a buying signal, which gives every email something specific to say.

01

May 2019

low
Campaign results for May 2019, 27 positive replies from 22,112 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, May 2019. 2,598 replies in total, 27 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

A specialist engineering recruiter in Coventry, seven consultants.

Problem

They had paid an agency to run outbound for five months on a retainer that cost more than a consultant's salary and produced a handful of meetings, none of which became a brief. They were also one of nine agencies on a preferred supplier list, so roles reached them only after the internal team had failed for six weeks.

Solution

Every company on the provider list got checked for ads that had been reposted, which is the signal that internal hiring has failed. Those hiring managers got an email about that exact role, with one candidate offered at an introductory fee. The first list came off job boards and was the same list every competitor was using, so it got rebuilt on companies whose ads had been live over 30 days. Every email named a specific role, so each one was checked by hand before it went out, which is why the list took three weeks to build before anything sent.

Result

27 positive replies. Every reply was passed over to their team. The reposted ad angle was the only one that got past the supplier list.

02

May 2020

low
Campaign results for May 2020, 20 positive replies from 16,813 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, May 2020. 1,617 replies in total, 20 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

A 14 person agency in Melbourne running a permanent desk.

Problem

Permanent hiring stopped in April and permanent was the only thing they did.

Solution

The list moved to sectors still hiring, supermarkets, logistics and aged care, aimed at the operations manager and, in the smaller groups, the owner. Contract cover replaced permanent search as the offer, which the desk had never sold before. A first attempt at their existing clients produced nothing but freeze notifications.

Result

20 positive replies. Replies were forwarded to their team. Not a good month, and it kept the desk alive.

03

August 2021

low
Campaign results for August 2021, 25 positive replies from 19,963 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, August 2021. 2,064 replies in total, 25 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

A 20 person agency in Chicago placing skilled trades.

Problem

Candidates were the scarce side of the market and clients would not pay upfront for a search nobody could promise to fill.

Solution

The email named the specific people already on their bench, with the skills spelled out, and offered an introductory fee on the first hire. Most of these were builders under 30 staff, so it went to the owner rather than a hiring manager. A generic availability email had gone out first and read like every other agency. Naming three real candidates changed it.

Result

25 positive replies. We forward the reply and stop there. Every reply was about a specific person, which is the point.

04

August 2023

average
Campaign results for August 2023, 35 positive replies from 20,258 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, August 2023. 1,809 replies in total, 35 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

A 15 person agency in Reading placing finance and operations roles.

Problem

Their pipeline swung on referrals from two old clients, so some months were full and others empty. Clients were also cutting agency spend and moving hiring in house.

Solution

Firms that had just cut their own talent team went on the list, since the hiring had not gone anywhere, and the offer was overflow support per role. The email went to the managing director, because the person who made that cut is the one who feels it. An earlier list of firms actively hiring was too competitive, and the pivot to firms who had just lost their recruiter was what opened it up. A version offering a discounted fee was dropped for inviting a negotiation before there was even a brief.

Result

35 positive replies. Each one was passed across to them. Losing an internal recruiter was the trigger, not an open role.

05

October 2024

strong
Campaign results for October 2024, 54 positive replies from 23,798 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, October 2024. 1,878 replies in total, 54 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

A 25 person agency in Perth placing construction and trades.

Problem

They had been buying job board credits and search ads for years, and the cost of a lead had passed the fee on a placement. Job ads also reached them at the same second as every other agency in the state.

Solution

A bought list of construction firms is just names. We enriched it against site approvals and project funding notices, which told us who was about to hire, and wrote to the operations lead weeks before a role existed. A version aimed at HR was slower and more procedural, so the list stayed on operations. The approvals data had to be cleaned by hand before any of it was usable, which is the unglamorous half of the job.

Result

54 positive replies. We hand the reply across and step out. Getting there before the ad was the entire advantage.

06

June 2025

great
Campaign results for June 2025, 67 positive replies from 16,886 people contactedValue private
Instantly panel, June 2025. 1,138 replies in total, 67 of them positive. Screenshot, not recreated.

A 12 person agency in Denver placing warehouse and driver temps.

Problem

The director had been running the outreach between client calls for four months. It cost almost nothing and never got a full week of anyone's attention, so it never built into anything. They still heard about roles only once the ad was live and four other agencies had called.

Solution

The provider list gave us the companies. Enriching it against new depot and second shift announcements gave us the week to write in, and the email went to the operations manager before the ad went up. Two of the first three angles were switched off inside a month. What held was the one naming the site and the shift pattern.

Result

67 positive replies across June. Replies go over to them, so we never see the close. New site announcements did more than any wording change.

Other markets we have run this in

Same method, different buyers. Every month on these pages is a dated screenshot.

AI automation and implementation4 documented months, median 37 positive repliesSee the campaignsB2B SaaS selling to SMB and mid-market6 documented months, median 30 positive repliesSee the campaignsCommercial cleaning, facilities and maintenance6 documented months, median 32 positive repliesSee the campaignsCommercial finance and B2B accounting6 documented months, median 32 positive repliesSee the campaignsFreight forwarding, 3PL and logistics7 documented months, median 31 positive repliesSee the campaignsManaged IT and cybersecurity6 documented months, median 23 positive repliesSee the campaignsManufacturing and industrial suppliers7 documented months, median 28 positive repliesSee the campaignsSoftware development and staff augmentation6 documented months, median 33 positive repliesSee the campaignsSpecialist marketing services6 documented months, median 26 positive repliesSee the campaignsVideo production6 documented months, median 29 positive repliesSee the campaignsWholesale, private label and B2B suppliers6 documented months, median 26 positive repliesSee the campaignsAll 12 marketsEvery market on one pageSee them all

Worth reading before a call

TargetingCold Email Targeting: How to Find the Right People and Verify They're RealRead itCold emailCold Email Agency vs In-House: Which Should You Choose?Read itPricingHow Much Does a Cold Email Specialist Actually Cost?Read it

Taking new campaigns

Want to see the numbers?

Send us who you sell to and roughly how many companies fit that description. One call is usually enough to tell whether the guarantee will hold for your market, and if it will not we would rather say so before you pay.